Dairy Store / Dairy Hunter’s Reserve Process Cheese Hunter’s Reserve Process Cheese Antonio Mozzarella Factory Antonio Mozzarella Factory Lancaster Cheese Lancaster Cheese Milk Milk Other Dairy Other Dairy Amish Roll Butter Amish Roll Butter Featured Products Sort by We recommend Newest arrivals Price: Low to High Price: High to Low Name: A to Z Name: Z to A 1 lb Amish Roll Butter 1 lb Amish Roll Butter $8.98 Pepperoni Rollatini (8 oz.) Pepperoni Rollatini (8 oz.) $6.98 Spinach Garlic and Sun-dried Tomato Rollatini (8 oz.) Spinach Garlic and Sun-dried Tomato Rollatini (8 oz.) $6.98 Butter Quarters (1 lb.) 4 sticks Butter Quarters (1 lb.) 4 sticks $4.99 Whipped Cream (14 oz.) Whipped Cream (14 oz.) $4.79 Sour Cream (16 oz.) Sour Cream (16 oz.) $3.79 Cream Cheese (8oz) Cream Cheese (8oz) $2.99 Farm Fresh Eggs Farm Fresh Eggs $6.00 Gallon of Milk Gallon of Milk $5.29 Chocolate Milk (1/2 Gallon) Chocolate Milk (1/2 Gallon) $4.39 1/2 Gallon of Milk 1/2 Gallon of Milk $3.29 Goat Cheese (4 oz.) Goat Cheese (4 oz.) $3.98 Colby Mini Cheese Wheel (12oz) Colby Mini Cheese Wheel (12oz) $5.98 Gouda Mini Cheese Wheel (12oz) Gouda Mini Cheese Wheel (12oz) $5.98 Chocolate Milk (14 fl oz) Chocolate Milk (14 fl oz) $2.99 Smoked Gouda Gourmet Spreadable Cheese(3.5oz) Smoked Gouda Gourmet Spreadable Cheese(3.5oz) $2.99 Pepper Jack Mini Cheese Wheel (12oz) Pepper Jack Mini Cheese Wheel (12oz) $5.98 Spicy Buffalo Cheddar Cheese (7.6oz) Spicy Buffalo Cheddar Cheese (7.6oz) $5.98